jump to navigation

Will somebody please take this job? November 6, 2009

Posted by Angelique in Animal welfare.
Tags: , , , , ,

Last week the Humane Society released another stomach-turning expose of the food animal industry. It’s an undercover video of a slaughter plant in Vermont that specializes in “bob veal,” which is veal from young (as in, a few days old) calves. The video goes beyond the predictably horrific. My personal favorite part is at the end, when the onsite USDA inspector who is supposed to ensure proper animal handling is giving a little friendly advice to the undercover agent. The agent, who had been hired into the plant as a floor cleaner, had called the attention of the workers and inspector to the fact that a calf on the assembly line was still moving. Afterward, the USDA inspector tells the agent, “You did the right thing…but next time just tell Frank or Terry. ‘Cause that’s something I’m not supposed to know. I could shut them down for that.”

Which reminds me that the US Department of Agriculture is just that – the department of agriculture. It is not the department of animal welfare, or even the department of consumer protection. Its mandate is primarily to support the agricultural industry, a fact which is evident when you read its strategic plan. Somewhere in the middle of that plan the USDA mentions food safety, and at the end it throws a bone to land protection. Nowhere does it discuss animal treatment, so we really shouldn’t expect that the USDA would concern itself with it.

The question is, if companies have no incentive to protect animal welfare, and the USDA has no incentive to protect animal welfare, then who does? People who care about animal welfare, presumably. That includes members of the Humane Society and similar organizations, but also regular Joes and Janes who prioritize animal welfare when they purchase (or choose not to purchase) animal-based products. So, how can we ensure that these people, who have an incentive to protect animal welfare, can actually protect it when it’s threatened, say in the environment of the farm or the slaughterhouse? The best answer is by giving them visibility into those places. Frankly every farm and slaughter facility should have webcams feeding sites where anyone who chooses can observe their activities. This is nearly but not completely unheard-of; some slaughter facilities already have cameras that feed Intranet sites that their customers log onto to observe how their own animals are handled.  

The second-best solution is for trusted third-party organizations to have this sort of visibility, if businesses are uncomfortable granting it to the general public. Companies that want to market their meat with certain certifications – say, Animal Welfare Approved, or Food Alliance certified – are already opening up their doors to these organizations for inspections. However, there is no certification of which I’m aware that covers the entire lifecycle of an animal, from farm to table. Most certifications cover only farms [BUT see comment to ths post from Beth at the Animal Welfare Institute – 11/7/09]. Food Alliance covers processors (in the meat industry, the euphemism for slaughterhouses), but separately from farms, so the fact that a product is labeled as Food Alliance certified does not guarantee both. And no one certifies transportation from farm to slaughterhouse to protect animal welfare during that process.

Who will step up to the plate to solve this problem?



1. Beth - November 7, 2009

Thank you Angelique for your articulate depiction of the issues at hand. I take this opportunity to let you know that Animal Welfare Approved http://www.AnimalWelfareApproved.org is a birth to slaughter program. As part of the annual audits conducted by experts in the field, each slaughter plant used by AWA farms is visited. A full time staff member of the AWA audit team conducts the plant visits. And there are standards in place to regulate transportation time from farm to slaughterplant.

As you know, Animal Welfare Approved prides itself in 1. certifying only true family farms, 2. offering the birth to slaughter audits free of charge to farmers (no incentive therefore to pass a given farm or plant) 3. the ONLY such third party certification that requires the animals be raised outdoors on pasture or range 4. USDA recognized and 5. providing free technical and marketing support to our family farmers.

Thank you for your post and stay in touch!

2. November 9 Morning Roundup « The Heavy Table - November 9, 2009

[…] following (featuring an æbleskiver pan!), Eating Animals points out that the USDA is not, repeat not the US Department of Animal Welfare, the Whitest Thing That Ever Happened*, the Second Whitest Thing That Ever Happened, a review of […]

3. Rick Tannenbaum - November 10, 2009

New Yorkers can take a small step toward easing the suffering of some farm animals by supporting Assembly Bill 8163. The bill bans hen battery cages, veal crates and pig gestation crates on New York farms by 2015. The bill is opposed by the New York Farm Bureau and the Chair of the Agriculture Committee William Magee. If they have their way, the bill will die in Committee. Magee and the NYFB represent the interests of NY’s medium and large CAFOs and other agribusiness interests. Learn more about the bill and what you can do at http://www.ab8163.com.

Rick Tannenbaum
The Hilltop Initiative

4. BorgisiopsVus - November 25, 2009

Great post, great looking weblog, added it to my favorites!

5. Book review: Slaughterhouse « From Animal To Meat - March 23, 2012

[…] out that the USDA has an inherent conflict of interest (something I’ve written about before here) and that agency bigwigs are often plucked straight from the companies they’re supposed to […]

6. Can a conscious death be humane? « From Animal To Meat - September 18, 2012

[…] on the article, I noted that while I agreed with Carlson that the USDA’s multiple mandates make it impossible for the agency to truly protect animal welfare, it was still possible to eat meat and dairy […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: